The Benefits and Potential Challenges of a Vegan Diet, with Oliver Patrick

In recent years, the debate surrounding dietary choices has intensified, with an increasing number of individuals considering the shift to a vegan lifestyle. Advocates on both sides passionately argue about the health benefits of vegan vs. omnivore (plant and animal foods) diets and, in the already complex world of modern nutrition, a sense of tribalism has arisen over different dietary philosophies. Exploring the comparative value of the vegan vs omnivore diet is a worthwhile exercise for individuals seeking to make informed choices about their health, the environment, and where they sit on the ethical implications of modern food production.

1. Nutritional Content.

One of the primary concerns in comparing vegan and omnivore diets is the nutritional content, with the original concerns over a vegan lifestyle being based on inadequate availability of key nutrients. This area can be summarised neatly to the conclusion both vegan and omnivore diets can deliver the body’s entire requirement for essential nutrients. However, the journey to ‘nourishment’ may not be as easily achieved through both methodologies. 

A well-planned vegan diet can offer an abundance of vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants, primarily derived from fruits, vegetables, grains, and legumes. On the other hand, an omnivore diet more readily provides an abundance of of protein, iron, vitamin B12, and omega-3 fatty acids. The research shows it is entirely possible to optimally nourished on a vegan diet, but an additional effort is required to achieve optimal levels of key nutrients less abundant in plant-based sources. 

2. Health Benefits of a Vegan Diet.

A recent documentary on Netflix ‘You Are What You Eat’ trialling identical twins (thereby negating genetic differences) on vegan diets vs omnivore diets, once again raised the question around superior health results from a vegan diet. 

The documentary argues positively for a vegan diet using improvements in key parameters such as cholesterol, weight, and other health markers in the vegan twin cohort. However, there may be some reasons for the health improvements beyond a simple vegetables vs meat debate. 

Data analysis shows the vegan twins ate significantly more fibre and a much reduced volume of saturated fat than their omnivore comparison. Added to this more polyunsaturated (‘healthy’) fats and a reduced total calorie intake and the difference is not so much due to veganism, but simply a better blend of nutrients and calories. It is fair to say these dietary improvements were enabled by the vegan diet but certainly not exclusive to the vegan philosophy. 

3. Concerns with an Omnivore Diet.

While an omnivore diet can offer certain nutrients that are challenging to obtain from plant-based sources, it is not without concerns. Excessive consumption of red and processed meats has been well linked to an increased risk of heart disease and certain cancers. Not all animal produce is equal in both impact on health and impact on the planet. Nor are all plant-based foods of equal benefit to human physiology. Nuance and context are key to a discussion such as this because there would be no such thing as a standard vegan or omnivore diet. 

4. Protein Intake.

Protein is a crucial component of a healthy diet, and both vegan and omnivore diets can meet the recommended protein intake. Plant-based sources such as legumes, tofu, and quinoa provide adequate protein, while animal products in an omnivore diet offer complete proteins with essential amino acids. It is essential for individuals following a vegan diet to ensure they combine various plant-based protein sources to obtain a complete amino acid profile, but it has been proven entirely possible to achieve. 

5. Vitamin B12 Considerations.

Vitamin B12, vital for nerve function and the formation of red blood cells, is primarily found in animal products. Vegans often need to supplement or consume fortified foods to meet their B12 requirements, as a deficiency can lead to anaemia and neurological issues. Omnivores, by contrast, can more easily obtain B12 from meat, eggs, and dairy products.

It is important to note that not all decisions in life are made with health in mind. And thankfully so! We must acknowledge that many individuals follow a vegan lifestyle for reasons beyond a potential improvement in underlying health.

6. Environmental Impact.

The environmental impact of dietary choices has become a significant factor in the decision-making process. The production of plant-based foods generally has a lower environmental footprint, with reduced greenhouse gas emissions and land use compared to the intensive livestock farming associated with omnivore diets. For those environmentally conscious, opting for a vegan diet may align with sustainable practices. However, that also does not tell the full story. There is a growing understanding around regeneratively reared meat and practices that are associated with sustainable farming being both incredibly good for carbon capture, soil health, biodiversity, and the maintenance of food culture and history in rural areas. 

7. Ethical Considerations.

Ethical considerations often influence individuals' dietary choices. Vegans argue that abstaining from animal products is a compassionate choice, promoting the wellbeing of animals and reducing their exploitation. On the other hand, omnivores may prioritise responsibly sourced and humanely raised animal products, supporting local and sustainable farming practices.

8. Pillar Approach. 

It's crucial to recognise that individual nutritional needs vary. Factors such as age, health status, and lifestyle can influence the suitability of a particular diet. Some individuals thrive on a vegan diet, while others may find an omnivore diet better suits their nutritional requirements. Personalised nutrition, considering individual health goals and preferences, should be at the forefront of dietary choices. It would be fair to say most individuals require more plant-based foods to access their abundance of nutrients such as fibre and antioxidants, as well as the impact on feeling full and controlling total calorie intake. However, these are features are entirely possible on an omnivore die. It is consistent dietary discipline around consumption of nourishing whole foods and minimising processed foods, rather than an overarching dietary philosophy, that will matter in the long run. 

Conclusion?

In the ongoing debate over the comparative value of a vegan diet versus an omnivore diet, it is essential to consider the holistic impact on health, the environment, and ethical perspectives. Both dietary choices can provide the necessary nutrients for a healthy life, but each comes with its unique considerations. Individuals should make informed decisions based on their nutritional needs, ethical beliefs, and environmental consciousness, recognising that there is no one-size-fits-all approach to diet and finding what suits you is ultimately the right choice. 

Follow us on Instagram to discover more about Pillar Wellbeing.